New York Court of Appeals Returns Vermont Teddy Bear Co. Lease Dispute To Trial Court
27 March 2004 - 10:32AM
PR Newswire (US)
New York Court of Appeals Returns Vermont Teddy Bear Co. Lease
Dispute To Trial Court SHELBURNE, Vt., March 26
/PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- The Vermont Teddy Bear Company(R) today
reported that the New York Court of Appeals reversed a judgment of
the lower court in the Company's favor in a lawsuit involving a
lease of retail space in New York City. The decision of the Court
of Appeals returns the case to the trial court for a determination
as to whether the lease was terminated after an incident inwhich
the premises leased by the Company were rendered uninhabitable when
the wall of the adjoining building collapsed. On October 24, 1996,
the Company entered into a ten-year lease for a retail store on
Madison Avenue in New York City. On December 7, 1997, the Company's
538 Madison Avenue location was closed due to the structural
problems at adjoining 540 Madison Avenue. The Company later
announced that it was permanently closing that retail location.
Pursuant to the lease, in the event of sucha casualty, the lease
would terminate if the leased premises were not restored within one
year. The City of New York deemed the 538 Madison Avenue building
uninhabitable from December 8, 1997 to April 9, 1998, and the
Company has not made any rent payments on the lease since December,
1997. On December 24, 1998, the Company received a notice from the
landlord alleging that the Company was in default under the lease
for failure to resume occupancy and demanding back rent. The
landlord had never previously advised the Company of the
restoration of the leased premises nor evidenced such restoration,
previously or at that or any subsequent point. On January 4, 1999
the Company received a demand to resume rent payments beginning
January 1999. The Company disputed the landlord's position and
believed it was not obligated to resume occupancy or pay rent under
the lease. As a result, on May 25, 1999, the Company commenced
action in the New York Supreme Court against the landlord, 538
Madison Realty Company. The Company sought breach of contract
damages and a declaration that the lease had been terminated. The
landlord moved to dismiss the action based on purported documentary
evidence, which motion was denied. The Company moved for summary
judgment on its claims and dismissal of the landlord's claims. The
Company's motion for summary judgment was granted by order dated
July 25, 2001 and judgment was entered in favor of the Company and
against the landlord in the amount of $211,146 on August 10, 2001.
The landlord appealed that judgment and posted a bond to stay
enforcement of the judgment pending its appeal. The judgment was
affirmed by New York's Appellate Division, First Department, and
the landlord appealed to the New York Court ofAppeals. On March 25,
2004, the Court of Appeals issued a decision reversing the
Appellate Division, and denying the Company's motion for summary
judgment. The decision by the Court of Appeals returns the case to
the Supreme Court for a determinationas to whether the Company's
lease was terminated or continued in effect following the December
7, 1997 incident. The Company will continue to pursue all of its
legal remedies to resolve the litigation favorably by decision or
settlement. According to Liz Robert, the Company's President and
CEO, "We continue to believe that the lease was terminated
according to its terms. We are disappointed that a trial may be
necessary, but we are ready to make our case." At this time no
trial date has been set. The foregoing can be interpreted as
including forward-looking statements under the Private Securities
Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Actual future results may differ
materially from those suggested by the statements above. Contact:
Nicole L'Huillier 802-985-1362 DATASOURCE: The Vermont Teddy Bear
Company CONTACT: Nicole L'Huillier of The Vermont Teddy Bear
Company, +1-802-985- 1362, Web site:
http://www.vermontteddybear.com/
Copyright
Vermont Teddy Bear (NASDAQ:BEAR)
Historical Stock Chart
From Oct 2024 to Nov 2024
Vermont Teddy Bear (NASDAQ:BEAR)
Historical Stock Chart
From Nov 2023 to Nov 2024
Real-Time news about Vermont Teddy Bear (MM) (NASDAQ): 0 recent articles
More Vermont Teddy Bear CO. (The) (MM) News Articles