Chinese Deals Draw Scrutiny In Washington
19 February 2016 - 7:03PM
Dow Jones News
(FROM THE WALL STREET JOURNAL 2/19/16)
By Shayndi Raice and William Mauldin
Chinese companies are winning in the M&A market. Now they
have to prove they can win in Washington.
Overseas takeover bids by Chinese companies are on pace for a
record year. Technology distributor Ingram Micro Inc. said
Wednesday it has agreed to a $6 billion offer from a unit of
Chinese conglomerate HNA Group, a deal that comes after China
National Chemical Corp.'s $43 billion agreement to buy Swiss
agriculture firm Syngenta AG and Haier Group's $5.4 billion bid for
General Electric Co.'s appliance unit.
The agreements have pushed the value of outbound Chinese
takeover announcements this year to $81.5 billion, according to
Dealogic -- far and away the fastest start ever for such deals. But
the U.S. government has been especially active, too, questioning
Chinese attempts to buy Western assets in sensitive sectors like
technology, as well as less obvious areas like light bulbs.
As a result, bureaucrats and politicians are playing an outsize
role as deal makers try to keep up with last year's record run for
mergers and acquisitions.
"China notably is the only one of our top trading partners that
is not a political ally, and the only one that is perceived as a
military competitor," said Mark Plotkin, a Washington-based partner
with the law firm Covington & Burling LLP. "Given the amount of
state ownership of Chinese companies, together with the history of
espionage between our countries and U.S. concerns about the
potential appropriation and proliferation of sensitive
technologies, Chinese investments present uniquely challenging
issues."
Full coffers, slowing growth at home and better prices abroad
thanks to the global equities selloff have made Chinese companies
strong candidates to make acquisitions.
"As China's growth starts to moderate, the U.S. and other
developed markets look attractive," said Michael Carr, the co-head
of global M&A at Goldman Sachs Group Inc.
But those considerations aren't always paramount. This week,
House Republicans asked the Obama administration to take a close
look at a Chinese firm's deal to buy the Chicago Stock Exchange.
The roughly 134-year-old exchange, which handles a tiny fraction of
U.S. equity trading, said this month it would be acquired by
Chongqing Casin Enterprise Group.
In a letter organized by Rep. Robert Pittenger (R., N.C.), 46
House Republicans asked the Committee on Foreign Investment in the
United States, or CFIUS -- the government body that screens foreign
takeovers for security concerns -- to conduct a "full and rigorous
investigation into this proposed acquisition."
The deal also made its way into the presidential race, with
Donald Trump raising questions about it in the latest Republican
debate.
CFIUS doesn't comment on which cases it is reviewing or their
outcome unless the president forbids a deal. The interagency body,
which is composed of representatives from a number of U.S.
departments including Homeland Security and Defense and led by
Treasury, is tasked with ensuring foreign acquirers don't pose a
risk to national security. If CFIUS determines that a transaction
poses such a threat, the president then has the ability to kill the
deal.
Another flashpoint for concerns about Beijing is a pending bid
by state-owned Zoomlion Heavy Industries Science & Technology
Co. to disrupt an agreed-upon merger between U.S. crane maker Terex
Corp. and Finland's Konecranes Oyj.
Rep. Duncan Hunter (R., Calif.) sent a letter Wednesday to
Treasury Secretary Jacob Lew asking him to investigate the Chinese
approach through CFIUS. Mr. Hunter said Terex provides critical
infrastructure to the departments of Defense and Homeland Security.
He said the fact that Zoomlion is a supplier of the People's
Liberation Army "demands that the agreement undergo thorough
scrutiny."
The biggest Chinese deal ever -- the proposed acquisition of
Syngenta -- also is expected to undergo intense scrutiny.
Syngenta's ownership of several U.S. chemical facilities that are
deemed potential terror targets could be a cause for CFIUS to
review the deal, lawyers say.
The resistance in Washington has some lawyers and bankers saying
that Chinese bidders are being saddled with an unofficial "CFIUS
premium" to make up for security concerns that could kill a deal.
Chinese buyers also typically agree to specific fees they will pay
should a deal get denied for security concerns. HNA, for instance,
would owe Ingram Micro $400 million if CFIUS scuttles the
transaction, a hefty 6.7% of the purchase price.
---
Liz Hoffman contributed to this article.
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
February 19, 2016 02:48 ET (07:48 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2016 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
ZoomLion Heavy Industry ... (PK) (USOTC:ZLIOY)
Historical Stock Chart
From Nov 2024 to Dec 2024
ZoomLion Heavy Industry ... (PK) (USOTC:ZLIOY)
Historical Stock Chart
From Dec 2023 to Dec 2024