DBRS Accuses Fed Of Discriminating Against Small Rating Firms
27 March 2009 - 1:00AM
Dow Jones News
The president of Canadian-based DBRS Inc., a rival to the big
three credit rating firms, accused the Federal Reserve on Thursday
of effectively shutting smaller rating firms out of the U.S.
securitization market.
In prepared testimony before the Senate Banking Committee,
Daniel Curry complained that asset-backed securities are eligible
to participate in the Fed's new Term Asset-Backed Securities Loan
Facility only if they receive a AAA-rating from Standard &
Poor's, Moody's or Fitch.
"No explanation has been given for the creation of this new
sub-category of registered credit rating agency," Curry said. "The
result of this is that DBRS ... has been deemed unqualified to rate
TALF-eligible securities, even though several issuers have asked it
to do so."
"The harmful effects of limiting rating agency competition under
the TALF are profound, because for the foreseeable future, the TALF
is likely to be the entire securitization market in the United
States," he added.
In 2006, Congress passed a bill aimed at promoting more
competition in the rating industry, improving transparency and
curbing conflicts of interest. Following the passage of that bill,
the Securities and Exchange Commission approved some rules to
implement the legislation.
But since the financial crisis, some critics have called for
expanding the SEC's authority beyond the scope of the bill because
they say the firms gave overly generous ratings to certain types of
debt.
Canada's DBRS has been officially designated by the SEC as a
nationally recognized statistical rating organization. That
designation, Curry noted, should make his company eligible to rate
securities for TALF.
Curry said he is trying to persuade the Fed to end its
"discriminatory policy."
-By Sarah N. Lynch, Dow Jones Newswires; 202-862-6634;
sarah.lynch@dowjones.com