Spain ETF Slumps On Weak Bond Auction - ETF News And Commentary
05 April 2012 - 5:17PM
Zacks
As 2012 has progressed, investors have been broadly spared from
the turmoil in many European markets. The PIIGS have managed to
keep their crises in check and stock markets have largely gained on
the lack of negative news, putting last year’s slump firmly in the
rear view mirror.
Yet while things have gone pretty smoothly so far this year, we
could be seeing a reversal to this trend here in the second
quarter. This shift looks to be due to the trillion dollar economy
of Spain and the impact that this enormous nation could have on the
broad euro zone and global growth at large (see more at the Zacks
ETF Center).
This could be due to growing investor trepidation regarding the
Spanish bond market, especially after the auction earlier this
week. In the issuance of medium term debt, the country sold just
over 2.5 billion euros of notes, putting the offering at the low
end of the 2.5 billion euro to 3.6 billion euro plan initially put
out by the government.
To top things off, the Spanish Prime Minister, Mariano Rajoy,
said that the country’s economic situation is one of ‘extreme
difficulty’ and that the country may need to ask for a bailout like
its peripheral counterparts have in months past. Given this
rhetoric and the difficult time the country may have in engaging in
more austerity, Spain might very well be in for some trouble later
this year, potentially throwing a wrench into the broad
recovery.
Thanks to this, the yields on benchmark 10 year Spanish
government debt spiked by about 25 basis points, pushing rates just
below the 5.7% level. This gain represented a 4.5% move in the
session and is in sharp contrast to what investors saw in early
March while yields were just below 5% (read Norway ETFs For Safer
European Plays).
This pulled down European ETFs across the board with most
products sinking by at least 2.5% on the session. Losses were
surprisingly led by funds in strong nations such as Germany or the
Nordic region, possibly due to perception that these countries will
have to take the brunt of any possible Spanish bailout in the near
future.
Nevertheless, it is not like the Spanish ETF
(EWP) escaped the broader European ETF turmoil on the day
either. The fund finished the day after the auction down about 2.8%
on heavy volume which was nearly five times what investors see on a
daily basis.
However, the losses haven’t been contained to this one trading
session as the product has seen severe weakness for quite some
time. In fact, the fund is down about 8.9% in year-to-date terms
while the European ETF has lost about 35.9% over the past 52 weeks
(see Three European ETFs Beyond The Euro Zone).
This performance is also in sharp contrast to not only broad
European ETFs but to other country specific funds as well. In fact,
the broad Euro Zone ETF (EZU) has added about 8.2%
in year-to-date terms while the still new Greek ETF
(GREK) has gained 2.7% in the time period in question.
As a result of this broad underperformance of EWP when compared
to its counterparts in the region, investors should start to wonder
if the product could be the next shoe to drop in the European
debacle. After all, it cannot be good news when the Spanish ETF is
underperforming other PIIGS funds by such a wide margin to start
2012.
Another reason for worry is EWP’s heavy exposure to financials.
The ETF allocates nearly 41% of its portfolio to the sector with
the vast majority going towards the broad banking industry. Given
that financials are among the worst places to be when fears of a
default are high, investors shouldn’t be surprised to see that this
ETF has struggled so far in 2012 (read German ETFs On The
Rise).
This is especially true when looking at some of the fund’s
biggest individual holdings. For example, Banco Santander
(STD), which makes up nearly one-fifth of the total
assets, is trading perilously close to its 52 week low having
posted a loss of nearly 14.3% in the past month alone.
So, given the heavy focus on banking in EWP and the increasingly
uncertain Spanish economy, most investors may want to stay out of
the fund at this time. The product is grossly underperforming the
rest of its PIIGS brethren and could now be poised to be the leader
on the downside in the near term (see Italian Bond ETFs: High Risk,
High Reward).
Thanks to these trends, the increasingly negative rhetoric from
the Spanish government, as well as the lack of focus on small PIIGS
like Ireland or Greece, and investors have a perfect storm in Spain
this year. As a result, we could definitely see more losses in this
volatile European ETF this year suggesting that if your portfolio
contains a long position in EWP it needs to be monitored extremely
closely now that the focus of the euro crisis appears to be zeroing
in on Spain.
Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research?
Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30
Days. Click to get this free report >>
BANCO SANTAN SA (STD): Free Stock Analysis Report
To read this article on Zacks.com click here.
Zacks Investment Research
Want the latest recommendations from Zacks Investment Research?
Today, you can download 7 Best Stocks for the Next 30 Days. Click
to get this free report
iShares MSCI Eurozone ETF (AMEX:EZU)
Historical Stock Chart
From Oct 2024 to Nov 2024
iShares MSCI Eurozone ETF (AMEX:EZU)
Historical Stock Chart
From Nov 2023 to Nov 2024