Blue Hill Doubles Down on Cloak of Secrecy and Unanswered Questions
10 October 2024 - 8:02AM
Territorial Bancorp Inc. (NASDAQ: TBNK) (“Territorial”) issued the
following statement regarding the presentation released today by
Blue Hill Advisors (“Blue Hill”):
For the fourth time, Blue Hill has failed to address questions
that are fundamental in any bank M&A transaction – How will you
pay for it? How will you obtain regulatory approval? How will
you close it? What are the assurances that you can do all of the
above?
Blue Hill’s inability to address these questions
further compounds the concerns associated with Blue Hill’s
illusory, non-binding and highly conditional preliminary indication
of interest.
- Blue Hill’s claims about “capital support” and AUM are
not committed financing. If Blue Hill is so
capable of backing its preliminary indication of interest, why
won’t it show proof of financing or even a financing
commitment? Why won’t Blue Hill show us the cash? Without
financing, Blue Hill’s preliminary indication of interest is simply
not real.
- Blue Hill has provided no information to
validate or support its claims that it could obtain the multiple
regulatory approvals needed to buy control of a bank. In fact, Blue
Hill’s lack of information all but ensures that regulatory
applications would be rejected as soon as they were submitted:
- The identity of many of Blue Hill’s supposed investors remains
a hidden secret as does the management team it would put in place
to run the Company. Why is Blue Hill refusing to disclose the names
of its investors and proposed management team? What is Blue Hill
hiding? No regulator – state or federal – would allow an anonymous
entity – much less “discrete” secret investors – to gain control of
a bank that is responsible for overseeing $1.57 billion1 in
deposits.
- Blue Hill hasn’t provided any information about how it or its
investors would address safety and soundness issues regarding
interest rate risk, liquidity, capital and earnings, which are
paramount to regulators.
- No information has been provided about Blue Hill’s claimed
M&A record, including which companies were involved in those
transactions and whether or not they were successful – or went
bankrupt.
- Blue Hill repeatedly names Allan Landon in its materials.
However, Mr. Landon is not a stated investor. What is Mr. Landon’s
role in Blue Hill’s transaction?
- Blue Hill has provided no information to give
assurance that it understands the regulatory review process. In
fact, its own statements make clear that Blue Hill has a
fundamentally failed understanding of what it will take to obtain
regulatory approval.
- Purchasing a bank is a complex process. The takeover of an
entire bank, as Blue Hill is seeking, is likely a controlled
acquisition. The coordinated efforts of six individuals, even if
“discrete” would likely be viewed as a group that is “acting in
concert.”
- Blue Hill has not previously applied for — nor secured —
regulatory approvals for any transaction of this size based on
information it has provided to Territorial.
- Blue Hill far underplays the significant obstacles it faces in
achieving regulatory approvals on a timely basis, if at all.
- Blue Hill’s belief that it can complete the 70%
tender offer it proposed is close to fantasy.
- Territorial has an approximately 50% retail shareholder base
and a highly fragmented institutional investor base.
- Given these facts, why should anyone believe what Blue Hill is
claiming? Once again, where is the documentation to support Blue
Hill’s assertions?
Additional considerations that are important for Territorial
shareholders to know:
- Territorial shareholders will not immediately receive any
payment for their shares while any transaction with Blue Hill
is sitting in regulatory limbo. Income taxes and the impact of the
regulatory delays on time-value-of-money mean that the net value of
Blue Hill’s preliminary indication of interest, if completed, would
be substantially less than what it has proposed.
- Blue Hill has provided no assurances that it wouldn’t reduce
its proposed value if the Hope Bancorp, Inc. (NASDAQ: HOPE) merger
agreement was terminated or following its unspecified "due
diligence." Indeed, Blue Hill has explicitly stated that its
indication of interest is “non-binding.”
- If Blue Hill is so confident in its ability to gain regulatory
approval, complete a tender offer and close a transaction, Blue
Hill could provide assurances to the Territorial Board and
shareholders through a legally binding “hell or highwater”
commitment. Yet, once again, Blue Hill is all talk, and no
substance.
- Blue Hill is simply not credible. It was only formed in 2023,
has offices in a residential home (which is for rent) and is
withholding material information.
- As a standalone, monoline, one- to four-family loan focused
bank, Territorial faces substantial business and regulatory risks –
even in a declining interest rate environment. The Company has been
operating at a loss over multiple quarters; loan growth is flat;
and revenues are declining. These and other factors led to the
Board’s decision to reduce the Territorial dividend as well as
enter into an agreement with Hope Bancorp. While these challenges
would be addressed by the Hope Bancorp merger, Blue Hill offers
nothing to deal with these challenges if the Hope Bancorp
agreement is terminated. Indeed, with Blue Hill and its undisclosed
“discrete” investors, Board and management team, Territorial’s
challenges could worsen.
The Territorial Board continues to unanimously recommend
that Territorial shareholders vote FOR the merger with Hope Bancorp
and all related proposals.
The combination with Hope Bancorp provides compelling value for
Territorial shareholders. The merger is structured as a 100% tax
free, stock-for-stock transaction under which Territorial
shareholders will receive 0.8048 shares of Hope Bancorp common
stock for each share of Territorial common stock they own. This per
share consideration represents an approximately 25% premium2 to
Territorial’s closing stock price just prior to the merger
announcement. In addition, the transaction has strong implied
transaction multiples across all relevant metrics, including
earnings per share and adjusted tangible book value per share.
With Hope Bancorp, Territorial will become a larger, more
diversified, more resilient business with increased resources to
invest and grow, resulting in increased value for Territorial’s
shareholders. Territorial shareholders will also realize a 1000%
increase in their dividend. For Territorial stakeholders, the
merger also provides meaningful benefits. As stated publicly:
- Upon close of the transaction, Territorial will continue to
operate under the Territorial name.
- Local branches and operations will be led by local teams, which
means Territorial’s customers can benefit from additional choices
and rely on the same people they know and respect.
- Employees will continue to receive competitive compensation and
benefits and will have additional career opportunities.
- Territorial’s legacy of community support and investment will
continue.
Territorial and Hope Bancorp have initiated the process for all
regulatory approvals, and the companies continue on the path to
close the transaction by the end of 2024.
Your Vote is ImportantTerritorial Shareholders are
Urged to Vote FOR the Hope Bancorp Merger TODAY.Voting is quick and
easy. Vote well in advance of the Special Meeting on November 6,
2024 at 8:30 a.m. HST.Call toll-free:(888) 742-1305Banks and
brokers should call:(516) 933-3100Email:
info@laurelhill.comElectronically: www.proxyvote.com |
About Us
Territorial Bancorp Inc., headquartered in Honolulu, Hawaiʻi, is
the stock holding company for Territorial Savings Bank. Territorial
Savings Bank is a state-chartered savings bank which was originally
chartered in 1921 by the Territory of Hawaiʻi. Territorial Savings
Bank conducts business from its headquarters in Honolulu, Hawaiʻi,
and has 28 branch offices in the state of Hawaiʻi. For additional
information, please visit https://www.tsbhawaii.bank.
Additional Information about the Hope Merger and Where
to Find It
In connection with the proposed Hope Merger, Hope has filed with
the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (the “SEC”) a
Registration Statement on Form S-4, containing the Proxy
Prospectus, which has been mailed or otherwise delivered to
Territorial’s stockholders on or about August 29, 2024, as
supplemented September 12, 2024. Hope and Territorial may file
additional relevant materials with the SEC. INVESTORS AND
STOCKHOLDERS ARE URGED TO READ THE PROXY PROSPECTUS, AND ANY OTHER
RELEVANT DOCUMENTS THAT ARE FILED OR FURNISHED OR WILL BE FILED OR
FURNISHED WITH THE SEC, AS WELL AS ANY AMENDMENTS OR SUPPLEMENTS TO
THOSE DOCUMENTS, CAREFULLY AND IN THEIR ENTIRETY BECAUSE THEY
CONTAIN OR WILL CONTAIN IMPORTANT INFORMATION ABOUT THE PROPOSED
TRANSACTION AND RELATED MATTERS. You may obtain any of the
documents filed with or furnished to the SEC by Hope or Territorial
at no cost from the SEC’s website at www.sec.gov.
Forward-Looking Statements
Some statements in this news release may constitute
forward-looking statements within the meaning of Section 27A of the
Securities Act of 1933, as amended, and Section 21E of the
Securities Exchange Act of 1934, as amended. These forward-looking
statements relate to, among other things, expectations regarding
the low-cost core deposit base, diversification of the loan
portfolio, expansion of market share, capital to support growth,
strengthened opportunities, enhanced value, geographic expansion,
and statements about the proposed transaction being immediately
accretive. Forward-looking statements include, but are not limited
to, statements preceded by, followed by or that include the words
“will,” “believes,” “expects,” “anticipates,” “intends,” “plans,”
“estimates” or similar expressions. With respect to any such
forward-looking statements, Territorial Bancorp claims the
protection provided for in the Private Securities Litigation Reform
Act of 1995. These statements involve risks and uncertainties. Hope
Bancorp’s actual results, performance or achievements may differ
significantly from the results, performance or achievements
expressed or implied in any forward-looking statements. The closing
of the proposed transaction is subject to regulatory approvals, the
approval of Territorial Bancorp stockholders, and other customary
closing conditions. There is no assurance that such conditions will
be met or that the proposed merger will be consummated within the
expected time frame, or at all. If the transaction is consummated,
factors that may cause actual outcomes to differ from what is
expressed or forecasted in these forward-looking statements
include, among things: difficulties and delays in integrating Hope
Bancorp and Territorial Bancorp and achieving anticipated
synergies, cost savings and other benefits from the transaction;
higher than anticipated transaction costs; deposit attrition,
operating costs, customer loss and business disruption following
the merger, including difficulties in maintaining relationships
with employees and customers, may be greater than expected; and
required governmental approvals of the merger may not be obtained
on its proposed terms and schedule, or without regulatory
constraints that may limit growth. Other risks and uncertainties
include, but are not limited to: possible further deterioration in
economic conditions in Hope Bancorp’s or Territorial Bancorp’s
areas of operation or elsewhere; interest rate risk associated with
volatile interest rates and related asset-liability matching risk;
liquidity risks; risk of significant non-earning assets, and net
credit losses that could occur, particularly in times of weak
economic conditions or times of rising interest rates; the failure
of or changes to assumptions and estimates underlying Hope
Bancorp’s or Territorial Bancorp’s allowances for credit losses;
potential increases in deposit insurance assessments and regulatory
risks associated with current and future regulations; the outcome
of any legal proceedings that may be instituted against Hope
Bancorp or Territorial Bancorp; the risk that any announcements
relating to the proposed transaction could have adverse effects on
the market price of the common stock of either or both parties to
the proposed transaction; and diversion of management’s attention
from ongoing business operations and opportunities. For additional
information concerning these and other risk factors, see Hope
Bancorp’s and Territorial Bancorp’s most recent Annual Reports on
Form 10-K. Hope Bancorp and Territorial Bancorp do not undertake,
and specifically disclaim any obligation, to update any
forward-looking statements to reflect the occurrence of events or
circumstances after the date of such statements except as required
by law.
Investor / Media Contacts:Walter IdaSVP,
Director of Investor
Relations808-946-1400walter.ida@territorialsavings.net
1 As of Jun 30, 20242 Based on Territorial and Hope Bancorp’s
closing prices as of Apr 26, 2024 (day before merger
announcement)
Hope Bancorp (NASDAQ:HOPE)
Historical Stock Chart
From Oct 2024 to Nov 2024
Hope Bancorp (NASDAQ:HOPE)
Historical Stock Chart
From Nov 2023 to Nov 2024