64. This is facially excessive and unfair to the Company. As described above, Malik, Jasinowski, and Black received $1,549,000, $837,000, and $293,000 respectively, from their 2018 NED Option Awards, which was intended to cover up to eight years of equity compensation (six years going back and two years going forward). Yet in one shot each of the non-employee Directors’ received True-Up Awards the value of which far exceeded what they had received for up to eight years of work.
65. The True-Up Awards were not supported by any peer analysis. Indeed, it does not appear that Northwest Biotherapeutics ever developed a peer group for compensation benchmarking purposes. If the Board had performed any sort of peer analysis, it would have revealed that the True-Up Awards could not possibly be justified from a market perspective.
66. For example, the following three companies recently listed Northwest Biotherapeutics as their peer for compensation purposes: Evoke Pharma, Inc. (“Evoke”), Isoray, Inc. (“Isoray”), and Navidea Biopharmaceuticals, Inc. (“Navidea”). During the 2020 fiscal year, these three companies paid their non- employee directors (who were on their respective boards the full year) average compensation packages valued at $170,960, $52,844, and $69,530, respectively.
67. Similarly, the following three companies recently listed Northwest Biotherapeutics as a competitor: Alaunos Therapeutics, Inc. (“Alaunos”), ImmunityBio, Inc. (“ImmunityBio”), and Kintara Therapeutics, Inc. (“Kintara”). During the 2020 fiscal year, these three companies paid their non-employee directors (who were on their respective boards the full year) average compensation packages valued at $64,752, $560,466, and $94,015, respectively.
68. By way of another example, TD Ameritrade has identified the following four companies, who are also developing cancer therapies, as peers of Northwest Biotherapeutics: Fate Therapeutics, Inc. (“Fate”), Fortress Biotech, Inc. (“Fortress”), Cyclacel Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (“Cyclacel”), and Plus Therapeutics, Inc. (“Plus”). During the 2020 fiscal year, these four companies paid their non- employee directors (who were on their respective boards the full year) average compensation packages valued at $337,641, $260,000, $83,079, and $155,410, respectively.
69. In fact, one would be hard-pressed to find even a handful of publicly- traded companies in the United States where non-employee directors are paid over $1 million each, let alone between $1.4 million and $4.27 million. For example, Frederic W. Cook & Co., Inc. (“F.W. Cook”), an executive and director compensation consulting firm, publishes an annual study of compensation paid to non-employee directors using 300 companies of various sizes and industries. In November 2020, F.W. Cook published its 2020 Director Compensation Report. For “small-cap” companies (those with market capitalization of less than $1 billion) such as Northwest Biotherapeutics, F.W. Cook found that the median, non-employee director compensation was $164,000, and the 75th percentile was $200,000. For “large-cap” companies (companies with a market capitalization greater than $5 billion), F.W. Cook found that the median, non-employee director compensation was $290,000, and the 75th percentile was $323,000.
70. Similarly, Steven Hall & Partners (“Steven Hall”), an independent compensation consulting firm, specializing exclusively in the areas of executive and director compensation, publishes an annual study of compensation to non-employee directors. Its “2020 Director Compensation Study” revealed that the median total compensation paid to non-employee directors at the 200 companies with the largest revenues in fiscal 2019 equaled just $315,000. In other words, with the True-Up Awards, the Company’s non-employee Directors paid themselves more than what many of the largest companies in the world pay their non-employee directors.
71. Powers, Goldman, and Boynton fare no better from a peer analysis perspective. With her $700,000 salary and $17,317,000 stock option award, Powers received total compensation of $18,017,000 in 2020. With his $525,000 salary and $10,548,000 in stock options, Goldman’s compensation package was valued at $11,073,000. And with a $5,950,000 stock option award and a $325,000 salary, Boynton’s compensation package was valued at approximately $6,230,000.
72. Meanwhile, the CEOs of Evoke, Isoray, and Navidea received compensation packages in 2020 valued at $1,171,210, $491,637, and $1,225,051, respectively. The CEOs of Alaunos, ImmunityBio, and Kintara paid their CEOS compensation packages in 2020 valued at $2,090,922, $490,248, and $1,054,476,