Covance CEO Sees Sound Fundamentals In Beleaguered Sector
07 May 2009 - 1:58AM
Dow Jones News
Covance Inc. (CVD) Chief Executive Joseph Herring sees the
fundamentals at contract research organizations, which perform
clinical trials, remaining solid as Big Pharma increases its
outsourcing in coming years.
But in the near-term, the sector is attempting to recover from a
remarkable turnaround in investor sentiment that has crushed the
once high-flying stocks.
Herring believes Covance, the largest in the sector, will
benefit from pharmaceutical companies cutting costs and improving
development efficiency as they deal with pipeline and patent
pressures. Furthermore, he expects the industry to actually get
some benefits from recent consolidation.
"We don't look at these three mergers with much fear," he said
in an interview Tuesday, referring to Merck & Co. Inc. (MRK)
buying Schering-Plough Corp. (SGO), Pfizer Inc.'s (PFE) deal for
Wyeth (WYE), and Roche Holding AG's (RHHBY) acquisition of
Genentech Inc.
He expects the combined companies to make some adjustments to
their pipelines in the three to six months after the deals close,
but doesn't see a major impact on the contract research
organization industry.
Because Wyeth doesn't outsource its preclinical work and
Schering-Plough doesn't outsource much overall, he expects the
acquiring companies to send trials from their the newly acquired
assets to contract research organizations.
"I can't predict the timing, but it feels to me like there is
some upside there," he said.
"Upside" is not a word that has been associated with the
contract research organization sector in the past year as the
stocks of the major players are all down more than 50%. Those
companies include Pharmaceutical Product Development Inc. (PPDI),
Charles River Laboratories International Inc. (CRL), Parexel
International Corp. (PRXL) and Icon Plc (ICLR).
The sector has long benefited from Big Pharma's increased
outsourcing of clinical work, a sentiment that drove gains of more
than 50% in the sector in 2007.
But the companies took a hit as the overall economy hurt drug
makers, causing ambitious expectations and growth to moderate for
contract research organizations.
Herring notes that Covance's stock was trading at 30 times
forward earnings in late September, compared to its current
multiple of 15.
He admits that the sector may have been irrationally valued at
the time, especially for a service company without any intellectual
property portfolio.
"Now I think it has now swung the other way... the truth is
probably somewhere in between," Herring said about the sector's
current market value.
Helping fuel the previous valuation was Covance's $1.6 billion
deal with Eli Lilly & Co. (LLY) in August to provide broad drug
development services over 10 years and assume control of Lilly's
early drug development facility and related workers.
At the time, many thought the ground-breaking deal would yield
many more like it. Although that hasn't happened, Herring is
confident more deals will come and notes that chief financial
officers at major drug makers have approached Covance out of
curiosity.
He described the Lilly deal as a "win-win" and expects drug
makers to close major research facilities in coming years in order
to increase their efficiency.
But in the near-term, Covance has hit some bumps in the road.
Last week, it lowered its 2009 financial projections, a move
mirrored by others in the sector.
The shortfall stemmed from slowing early-stage workflow, paired
with a decision to maintain its work force and "weather the
storm."
Herring notes that later-stage work remains strong, and he
expects early stage work to pick up in the second half as companies
restart delayed projects.
Furthermore, Covance's top-five clients are under contract to
conduct a certain amount of work for the year, and they are
expecting to meet those minimums, Herring said.
Despite some worry that pharmaceutical research and development
spending is shrinking, Covance projects it will grow by 2% to 4%
for the next three to five years, at the minimum.
Even if that projection is wrong, Herring notes that the
industry can maintain healthy growth as long as outsourcing
continues.
He stresses that large pharmaceutical companies will turn to
contract research organizations to cut costs, become more flexible
with remaining expenses, and accelerate the development of their
pipelines.
"I think outsourcing is going to substantially increase,"
Herring said.
-Thomas Gryta; Dow Jones Newswires; 201-938-2053;
thomas.gryta@dowjones.com