Pinnacle Stockholders for Representation Issue Open Letter to Stockholders
08 March 2012 - 1:00AM
Wayne King, Private Investor, and Ryan Morris of Meson Capital
Partners, LLC, the general partner of Meson Capital Partners, LP
(the "Pinnacle Stockholders for Representation"), holders of
1,182,466 shares or 6.18% of the Pinnacle Airlines, Corp.
(Nasdaq:PNCL) ("Pinnacle" or the "Company"), today release an open
letter to stockholders.
Dear Fellow Pinnacle Stockholders:
In our December 23, 2011 press release, we called on Pinnacle to
promptly appoint two stockholder representatives to the board.
We were contacted by dozens of individual stockholders and
received universal support for our proposal. We encouraged all
stockholders to communicate their views directly to
Pinnacle. On February 17, 2012 we met with Donald Breeding,
Chairman of the Board, and Susan Coughlin, Director and Head of the
Nominating and Corporate Governance Committee to discuss the merits
of our proposal.
At the meeting, we alerted the Pinnacle representatives to the
current outrage among stockholders due to the following:
- 93% drop in Pinnacle's market value (currently at $24mm) since
January 1, 2007.
- Non-performing capital investments of $173mm since January 1,
2007.
- A mere 1.09% share ownership by the eight non-employee
Directors.
- Virtually no shares purchased in the open market by Board
members in the last 5 years.
- Outsized board compensation vs. market value, compared to
peers.
- Corporate bylaws designed to entrench current board
members.
- Lack of transparent communications with stockholders.
Without meaningful ownership at the board level, Pinnacle
Stockholders for Representation believes board and stockholder
financial incentives are dangerously out of alignment. Warren
Buffett insightfully remarked, "Who bothers to take a rental car to
the car wash?" By appointing us to the board (stockholders who
collectively own 6.18%), the board could immediately begin to
correct this critical misalignment. We emphasized to Mr.
Breeding and Ms. Coughlin that a rejection of our proposal would
force us to engage in an expensive and time consuming proxy contest
in which we would nominate three directors for a stockholder vote
at the Company's annual meeting in May 2012.
Our proposal offers Pinnacle's board a golden opportunity to
make a positive, pro-active, stockholder friendly move that would
begin rebuilding stockholder trust: a root problem that is easily
fixed with stockholder representation on the board.
Regrettably, the board has responded to our proposal with a
de-facto rejection, claiming that "it is not the 'concept' of
adding you to the board that we are struggling with. It is the
timing." In addition to this rejection, the board has
disenfranchised stockholders by indefinitely delaying the annual
meeting, originally scheduled for May 2012.
We could not disagree more with the board's stated reason for
rejecting our proposal on the basis of bad "timing." Indeed,
we believe strongly that NOW, during this chaotic period for the
Company, where decisions with long term consequences for
stockholders will be made, is EXACTLY the time when stockholder
representation is needed most. An expensive and
time-consuming proxy contest is not in the best interest of
all parties, yet the board has currently chosen a path of
entrenchment that leads directly to it.
We reiterate that we are supportive of CEO, Sean Menke and
applaud the progress he is making and the intellectual honesty with
which he is approaching the significant hurdles facing
Pinnacle. We believe that, by choosing to engage in a proxy
contest and not being open to stockholder representation at this
critical juncture, the board is dangerously undermining Mr. Menke's
efforts to transform Pinnacle into a sustainable enterprise.
Entrenchment tactics will not work. As one stockholder who
contacted us said: "Enough is enough!" Delaware law permits
the court to order an annual meeting if management does not call
one within 13 months after the previous meeting on May 17, 2011 and
we are fully prepared to petition the court to order an annual
meeting.
There has never been a more critical time for Pinnacle
stockholders to have proper representation. We urge the board
to listen to the Company's stockholders and to accept our proposal
today.
Thank you for your support as fellow owners of the Company,
Pinnacle Stockholders for Representation
Investor Contacts:
Wayne King (wayne.king.908@gmail.com), 908-273-3209
Ryan J. Morris (rmorris@mesoncapital.com), 607-216-8905
Stockholders can contact the Pinnacle board at
investorrelations@pncl.com
THE PARTICIPANTS IN THE SOLICITATION AND THEIR DIRECT OR
INDIRECT INTERESTS IN PINNACLE ARE: DIRECT OWNERSHIP BY WAYNE KING
OF 618,664 SHARES OF COMMON STOCK (APPROXIMATELY 3.23% OF
PINNACLE'S COMMON STOCK) AND DIRECT AND INDIRECT OWNERSHIP BY RYAN
MORRIS, MESON CAPITAL PARTNERS, LLC, AND MESON CAPITAL PARTNERS, LP
OF 563,802 SHARES OF COMMON STOCK (APPROXIMATELY 2.95% OF
PINNACLE'S COMMON STOCK). WHEN A PROXY STATEMENT IS COMPLETED AND
FILED, PINNACLE SECURITY HOLDERS ARE ADVISED TO READ THE PROXY
STATEMENT BECAUSE IT WILL CONTAIN IMPORTANT INFORMATION, AND
SECURITY HOLDERS SHOULD RELY ON SUCH PROXY STATEMENT AND NOT ON
THIS RELEASE. THE PROXY STATEMENT AND ANY OTHER RELEVANT DOCUMENTS
RELATED TO SOLICITATION OF PROXIES WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR NO CHARGE
AT THE SEC'S WEBSITE, WWW.SEC.GOV.
Pinnacle Airlines (NASDAQ:PNCL)
Historical Stock Chart
From Mar 2025 to Apr 2025
Pinnacle Airlines (NASDAQ:PNCL)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2024 to Apr 2025