US SEC, CFTC Seek Exchange Data On Co-Location Fees, Access
25 September 2009 - 6:33AM
Dow Jones News
U.S. regulators are asking exchanges to reveal the pricing and
access rules around co-location services, which allow traders to
place their servers in the same building as the platform.
The practice helps reduce execution times, and the requests are
a broader review of high-frequency trading.
The Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures
Trading Commission are also seeking information on the volume of
trading from co-location, according to exchange officials.
Trading firms pay market operators to place electronic terminals
in the same buildings that house exchanges' servers.
While not a new concept, co-location has caught Washington's eye
as regulators and lawmakers assess the growing role that
high-frequency traders play in U.S. markets.
High-frequency trading firms, mostly private enterprises that
execute millions of trades a day in pursuit of oft-tiny spreads,
are now estimated to account for two-thirds of all stock trades in
the U.S. Their presence is increasingly felt in derivatives markets
as well.
Among regulators' chief concerns are that co-location services
don't put any one type of market participant at a disadvantage,
creating a two-tiered market that advantages those who can pay up
for the best access.
Executives at NYSE Euronext (NYX) and Nasdaq OMX Group Inc.
(NDAQ) said that the SEC will soon require exchanges to publish
their co-location pricing alongside other exchange fees, with
regulators able to approve or disapprove co-location fee
schedules.
"What the SEC is concerned with, and what we're concerned with,
is that anybody who wants that kind of access to a marketplace can
do so, and do so in a fair, transparent way," said Eric Noll, head
of transaction services for Nasdaq OMX.
From the exchange perspective, offering co-location creates a
level playing field - any trading firm that wants to take advantage
of close proximity can pay a standard fee and get the same speed as
any other firm co-locating their trading systems in the same place
as the exchange's infrastructure.
"All the high-frequency traders want is to make sure they're not
at a disadvantage to anyone else," said Lawrence Leibowitz, global
technology chief for NYSE Euronext. "Our goal is to have everybody
on the same level."
Most exchanges, like Nasdaq OMX, Direct Edge and BATS Exchange,
maintain partnerships with data center operators like Verizon
Communications Inc. (VZ) and Equinix Inc. (EQIX) to provide
co-location for high-speed trading outfits.
NYSE Euronext is building its own 400,000 square foot data
center in Mahwah, N.J.
To a certain extent, Leibowitz said, exchanges have to offer
co-location - if they didn't, a third party could buy the building
next to an exchange's data center and rent out rack space to the
highest bidder, promising the lowest possible latency.
"It's like real estate," he said.
Nasdaq OMX's Noll noted that co-location is about more than
speed of trading. Locating firms' trading systems within the same
facility as exchange servers ensures better security and a
sustained connection to the marketplace, he said.
-By Jacob Bunge, Dow Jones Newswires; (312) 750 4117;
jacob.bunge@dowjones.com
(Sarah Lynch contributed to this article.)