Circuit City's Fall Aiding Sales, Vendor Deals For Survivors
06 February 2009 - 6:35AM
Dow Jones News
Business updates from regional electronics chains HHGregg (HGG)
and Conn's (CONN), as well as Costco Wholesale Corp. (COST),
confirm that Circuit City Stores Inc.'s (CCTYQ) rivals are already
benefiting from its demise.
Companies reported better purchasing terms with vendors in
recent months. And some are already seeing improved opportunities
to add stores or add them more cheaply in light of the growing
number of vacant storefronts generated by the failures of Circuit
and other retailers.
"We are aggressively pursuing Circuit City's old market share
and are optimistic the expected market-share gains will benefit our
business over the long term," said Dennis May, HHGregg's president
and operating chief, during a conference call with analysts and
investors.
Retailers' profit margins and store traffic could be pressured
over the next two months as more shoppers are attracted to
potential deals at Circuit City. The chain's remaining 567 U.S.
stores are scheduled to close by April, though industry watchers
expect liquidation sales to wind down earlier.
Still, industry analysts on Thursday were encouraged that
Costco, HHGregg and Conn's each indicated TV sales stayed strong in
January despite the liquidation and the economy. So far, it doesn't
seem as though the liquidation sales have eaten into the chains'
business.
Furthermore, TV manufacturers seem to have corrected an
oversupply that sent selling prices plummeting over the holidays,
and retail inventories seem quite lean, said Credit Suisse analyst
Gary Balter. That could be good for pricing in general for the
remaining retailers, he said in a note to clients.
Shares of HHGregg jumped 17.1% to $9.60; Conn's gained 9.5% to
$12.61 recently, and shares of Best Buy Co. Inc. (BBY), the largest
U.S. specialty electronics retailer by sales, rose 6% to
$29.68.
Costco shares were up 0.5% at $43.18 after the retailer warned
Wednesday of disappointing fiscal second-quarter earnings as the
recession cut into sales of other nonfood items and into profit
margins.
HHGregg's better-than-expected fiscal third-quarter earnings
were largely due to what the Indianapolis-based chain called
"favorable buying opportunities" with TV vendors as a result of
Circuit's woes and a general oversupply among TV vendors. As a
result, HHGregg could offer good deals to shoppers and offset some
economy-driven sales weakness while boosting gross margin more than
analysts had expected.
HHGregg, which has about 100 stores predominantly in the Midwest
and Southeast, reported a double-digit percentage increase in TV
units sold at comparable stores for the third quarter. The company
has baked into its fourth-quarter outlook increased pressure on
store traffic and prices from the liquidation sales.
Club retailing giant Costco, too, said vendors offered it
attractive TV-buying opportunities over the past several months as
it reported January unit sales growth of 80% in TVs.
Conn's, which has 76 stores in Texas, Louisiana and Oklahoma,
posted a nearly 13% increase in same-store sales for the Jan.
31-ended quarter as flat-panel TV sales drove big growth in
consumer electronics.
"The company's performance was strong in each of the three
months of the quarter, benefiting in part, we believe, from the
demise of a variety of national and local competitors," said Hudson
Square Research analyst Scott Tilghman.
Retailers are gaining leverage with more than just TV
suppliers.
HHGregg's ratio of advertising expenses to sales improved in the
quarter despite a 13.2% drop in same-store sales. May said in an
interview that most of the leverage in advertising costs was tied
to the soft economy and the resulting pullback from other
advertisers, such as car dealers. Still, he noted, consumer
electronics retailers favor certain forms of advertising. With
Circuit City out of the picture, he said, "As we look into the next
year, we see ourselves being in the driver's seat around
negotiating aggressive advertising runs."
Real-estate market conditions are also proving more favorable to
those few retailers still expanding.
HHGregg said landlords are more willing to negotiate on prices
and terms of leases. As a result, the chain plans to shift from new
construction to overhauling existing storefronts as it adds stores.
And it could enter some markets that didn't previously make sense
financially because they were overpriced, executives said. They
didn't spell out expansion plans for fiscal 2010, saying they'll
balance opportunities with the need to grow profitably and the need
to manage working capital cautiously in light of the economy.
"We felt like before this that our (business) model created a
great runway for growth," said Chairman and Chief Executive Jerry
Throgmartin during a conference call. "We think that's greatly
enhanced in this situation."
-By Mary Ellen Lloyd, Dow Jones Newswires; 704-948-9145;
maryellen.lloyd@dowjones.com