2nd UPDATE: US Chamber: Press Event On Climate A Fraud
20 October 2009 - 8:09AM
Dow Jones News
The U.S. Chamber of Commerce said it was the victim of fraud
Monday after a group claiming to represent the organization said
the Chamber had switched its position on climate change.
A Chamber of Commerce spokesman said he broke up a group holding
a fake press briefing at the National Press Club stating that the
Chamber now supports the science of climate change and stringent
legislation to curb greenhouse gas emissions. He said the group
used a chamber emblem at the briefing.
The spokesman said the Chamber hasn't questioned the science of
climate change but rather some of the policies that Democratic
leaders are pursuing to cut greenhouse gases. The Chamber is
investigating those responsible for the event.
"The irresponsible, and possibly illegal, tactics are a foolish
distraction from the serious effort by our nation to reduce
greenhouse gases." Senior Vice President for Communications and
Strategy Thomas Collamore said later in a statement. "The U.S.
Chamber believes that strong climate legislation is not
incompatible with the goals of improving our economy and creating
jobs. We continuously seek opportunities to engage in a
constructive dialogue to achieve these goals," he said in a
statement.
An individual who called himself Andy Bichlbaum contacted Dow
Jones Newswires said his group, the "Yes Men," claimed
responsibility for the fabrication.
"We're trying to get information about climate front-and-center
in the media and put pressure on big business to do the right
thing," he said. The stunt comes as the Yes Men launch a movie of
the group's escapades. Previous stunts have targeted Exxon Mobil
Corp. (XOM) and Dow Chemical Co. (DOW).
The hoax comes after several prominent businesses left the
Chamber in recent weeks, saying the organization doesn't represent
their views on climate legislation. Environmental groups have
highlighted the departures in a press campaign as part of an effort
to pressure the Chamber to change its opposition to climate
legislation under consideration in Congress.
The fraudulent press briefing was reported as news by several
organizations, including Reuters, CNBC and Fox Business. Reuters
later issued a correction on the story. Fox Business is a unit of
News Corp. (NWS, NWSA), which owns Dow Jones & Company,
publisher of this newswire.
A Fox Business spokeswoman said the agency corrected the report
within a minute of announcing the fraudulent event. Donna Leinwand,
president of the National Press Club, said officials challenged the
legitimacy of the event about an hour before it started, and a
Chamber official disbanded the briefing within a few minutes.
The group, whose fraudulent Web site was registered under
"Support and Commitment, Inc.," is believed to be behind other
similar hoaxes.
The group also sent out a fraudulent invitation for the fake
event Monday. Quoting a nonexistent press officer named "Hingo
Sembra," the invitation said: "We believe that strong climate
legislation is the best way to ensure American innovation, create
jobs, and make sure the U.S. and the world are on track to reduce
global carbon emissions, and to provide for the needs of the
American business community for generations to come."
An "Erica Avidus," listed as a contact on the release, didn't
return calls. The root of "Avidus" in Latin refers to greed.
Telephone numbers listed in the fake invitation and for the
registered owner of the Web site weren't listed in directory
assistance. An email to the contact wasn't returned, and the
registered street address for the Web site owner doesn't exist.
On the Web site, Chamber President Thomas Donohue is
fraudulently quoted in a prepared speech. "We at the Chamber have
tried to keep climate science from interfering with business," the
fraudulent remarks said. "But without a stable climate, there will
be no business. We need business more than we need relentlessly
higher returns."
A Chamber spokesman said the organization hadn't yet determined
whether it would turn its investigation over to the authorities,
but noted that there was possible wire fraud and unauthorized use
of the Chamber's trademark.
Yes Men's "Bichlbaum" said the risk for prosecution, "is a risk
worth taking."
He said although lawyers advised against such hoaxes, warning of
the legal implications of fraud, others said: "You've got right on
your side and in the court of public opinion you'll win."
"We do invite the Chamber to ask those questions, it would
invite more attention," he said.
-By Ian Talley, Dow Jones Newswires, 202-862-9285;
ian.talley@dowjones.com