By Newley Purnell
BANGKOK--A gathering that Thai officials held Thursday to
discuss online anticoup dissent didn't go as planned for the
military--because there were no social-networking companies in
attendance.
"There are no social-media operators are here at all," Maj. Gen.
Pisit Paoin, adviser to the Ministry of Information and
Communication Technology's permanent secretary, told media after
the meeting, noting that he had personally phoned representatives
from Facebook and Google to invite them.
Several Thai Internet service providers where on hand, but
representatives from the world's biggest social network and the
world's most dominant search engine were nowhere to be found, he
said. Google and Facebook spokeswomen declined to comment on any
invitation or questions about the army's approach to Internet
censorship.
The incident illustrates a challenge that the ruling junta,
known as the National Council for Peace and Order, faces following
the military's first putsch of the smartphone age: Cyber critics
are elusive, and the platforms they use to assail the powerful
armed forces operate beyond Thailand's shores.
Maj. Gen. Pisit noted that officials will travel to Singapore to
discuss the issue with Google and Facebook next month, and would
consider visiting the headquarters of Japan-based Line--Thailand's
most popular smartphone messaging app--at a future date.
Users have taken to Line and other services to organize
antimilitary demonstrations since the putsch, and Maj. Gen. Pisit
said blocking some individual users' Line accounts was "in
progress."A Line spokeswoman, however, said the company hasn't been
contacted by Thai authorities and that none of its users have been
blocked.
Army officials have reiterated since they came to power last
week that they won't tolerate social-media postings that denigrate
the army or the country's royal family, but have not explained how
they plan to block individual users without affecting entire social
networks like Facebook and Twitter, which are hugely popular in
Southeast Asia's second-largest economy.
"I think they may know what has happened in places like Turkey,
but don't know if they would like to follow in their footsteps,"
said outspoken Thai academic Pavin Chachavalpongpun, associate
professor at the Center for Southeast Asian Studies at Kyoto
University.
Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan has undertaken a
concerted effort to block websites and collect Web browsing data on
individuals, leading to concerns among policy makers and Internet
companies that Turkey could be used as a template for leaders in
other nations who want to control Internet use without as much
force as China or Iran.
For some, a prelude to the Thai military's tactics came on
Wednesday, when Facebook--used by a large proportion of Thailand's
67 million people --briefly became unavailable, prompting outraged
users to speculate on Twitter that it had been disrupted by the
military. The army denied severing links to the site, however, and
blamed the outage on a technical glitch.
Mr. Pavin, is one of those flouting the military's rules: When
he was summoned recently to report to the army, he responded by
posting a photo of his pet Chihuahua on Facebook. The irreverent
message: He'd send his mutt, named Mooyong, to meet with troops in
his stead.
"The political battlefield is no longer confined to the streets
of Bangkok. It's moved into cyberspace," said Mr. Pavin. "This is
the power of social media."
The global technological landscape has evolved dramatically in
the years since 2006, when the military launched its previous
military intervention. When the army unseated then-prime minister
Thaksin Shinawatra, who was accused of corruption and disloyalty to
the country's royal family, Facebook was just over two years old,
and the iPhone had yet to be released.
Today Facebook has more than one billion global users and
Thailand's smartphone penetration rate has risen to 49%, according
to data from research firm Nielsen.
"The military strategy is for immediate control, and then
they'll manage the fallout later," said Singaporean academic James
Gomez, who studies politics and social media.
If the Thai junta blocks social-media activity, users will
simply use workarounds.
"A key value of social media is the ability to mobilize," he
said. "They're trying to diminish that capability. The political
grievances will continue."
Nopparat Chaichalearmmongkol in Bangkok contributed to this
article.
Write to Newley Purnell at newley.purnell @wsj.com
Subscribe to WSJ: http://online.wsj.com?mod=djnwires