CQS Natural Resources Growth and Income
PLC
29 January 2025
INTERVIEW WITH THE CHAIR AND FUND
MANAGERS, EDISON RESEARCH NOTE & REMINDER TO VOTE AGAINST
SABA'S PROPOSALS
The Board of CQS Natural Resources Growth and Income PLC (the
"Company") urges all Shareholders to vote on the resolutions
requisitioned by Saba Capital Management, L.P. ("Saba") (the
"Requisitioned Resolutions") and set out in the Circular for the
Company's forthcoming requisitioned general meeting to be held at
11 a.m. on 4 February 2025 (the "Requisitioned General
Meeting").
The Board recommends Shareholders to
VOTE
AGAINST all Requisitioned Resolutions to protect your
investment for the reasons set out in the Circular and outlined
below.
A copy of the Circular has been submitted to
the National Storage Mechanism and is available on the Company's
website at https://ncim.co.uk/cqs-natural-resources-growth-and-income-plc/
and microsite at https://cynprotectyourinvestment.com/.
The deadline to vote is 31 January, however,
customers
of online share
ownership platforms may have voting deadlines of 30 January or
earlier. See below for the full list of
deadlines.
On 24th January, CYN Chairman, Chris
Casey, together with joint fund managers Rob Crayfourd and Keith
Watson, were interviewed by Donald Leggat for TickerTV, during
which they outlined the fund and its performance, as well as the
key points to consider in voting AGAINST Saba's
resolutions. The interview can be found
here:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U1T4VAk11Nw&list=PPSV&t=2s
Edison
Research publishes report: CYN - A natural resources specialist
worth preserving
Edison has published a research note "CQS
Natural Resources Growth and Income - A natural resources
specialist worth preserving". The note sets out the main objectives
of the Company, investing in a broad portfolio of mining and
resource equities, in addition to outlining Saba's opportunistic
arbitrage strategy to exploit the discounts to NAV among UK-listed
investment trusts. Read the full note here:
https://www.edisongroup.com/research/a-natural-resources-specialist-worth-preserving/BM-1120/
Why vote
AGAINST:
Performance
and incorrect benchmark
Saba have put forward misleading information on
the performance of the Company, using the incorrect reference
benchmark and ignoring the Company's significant exposure to metals
and mining. The Board has overseen strong performance, with 167%
total return in NAV and 220% total return in share price since the
current joint fund managers were appointed in October
2015[1].
Corporate
governance and management
The Company's regular and transparent
communication, share buybacks, and an annual continuation vote
provide Shareholders with the tools they need to make an informed
investment decision and a voice for the future of their
company.
The current Board is fully independent and has
deep experience in investment trusts, natural resources, the UK
investment management sector, finance and accounting, and as
directors of quoted companies. The two proposed directors nominated
by Saba have none of this sector experience or understanding of the
UK market, nor do the Board believe they are independent. If Saba
select themselves as investment manager, there is a potential
conflict of interest.
Saba
investment strategy
Saba have not outlined a clear path for the
investment strategy or the future of your investment, should their
Requisitioned Resolutions be passed.
Saba's proposals therefore introduce new and
significant risk to your investment, potentially trapping
Shareholders at a long-term discount in an entity which is no
longer a highly specialised natural resources investment trust.
Their proposals are not in the best interests of ALL
Shareholders.
Glass Lewis,
PIRC, and ISS align with Board recommendations
Proxy advisors Glass Lewis, PIRC, and ISS have
all recommended that Shareholders in the Company vote AGAINST the
Requisitioned Resolutions proposed by Saba; this is in line with
the unanimous recommendations of the Board.
Christopher
Casey, Chair of CQS Natural Resources Growth and Income PLC,
commented:
"Saba is not
the saviour of your company. They have misrepresented the Company's
performance, have no clear path to add value to all Shareholders
and have provided questionable governance proposals. Saba's own
performance in the US is inconsistent at best, given that their
management of two funds has not led to a long-term narrowing of the
discount, and introduces significant risk to your
investment.
"We remind
Shareholders that if you do not vote against their resolutions,
Saba's 29.07% shareholding may bulldoze the result without support
of the majority of Shareholders.
"As we get
closer to voting deadlines, the Board urges all Shareholders who
have yet to vote to make their voice heard, and vote to protect
their investment from self-interested and misleading proposals put
forward by Saba.
"The Board
and three proxy advisor agencies, Glass Lewis, PIRC, and ISS,
unanimously recommend you vote against the resolutions proposed by
Saba to protect your investment in your Company."
How
to Vote
The Requisitioned General Meeting to vote on
the Requisitioned Resolutions will be held on 4 February 2025 at 11
a.m. at the offices of Dentons UK and Middle East LLP at One Fleet
Place, London, EC4M 7RA.
To be valid, proxy appointments must be
completed in accordance with the instructions accompanying it and
transmitted so received by the Registrar as soon as possible and,
in any event, by no later than 11 a.m. on 31 January
2025.
Investors who hold their shares through an
investment platform provider or nominee are encouraged to contact
their investment platform provider or nominee as soon as possible
to arrange for VOTES AGAINST each of the Requisitioned
Resolutions to be lodged on their behalf. Please note: customers
of online share ownership
platforms may have voting deadlines of 30 January or
earlier.
Further information on how to vote through
platforms can be found at the following link: https://www.theaic.co.uk/how-to-vote-your-shares.
The Company has appointed Boudicca (part of
Equiniti Group) to liaise with Shareholders to ensure that the Form
of Proxy is completed and submitted by the deadline. If you need
further information or assistance in voting your Shares, please
email EQProxyEngagement@equiniti.com or
telephone 0371 384 2452 (between 9.00 a.m. and 5.00 p.m. (UK time)
Monday to Friday) for information.
Retail voting
deadlines:
AJ Bell voting deadline
|
30 January
|
Hargreaves Lansdown voting deadline
|
30 January
|
Interactive investor voting deadline
|
30 January
|
Proxy filing deadline
|
11 a.m. on 31 January
|
Record time and date for entitlement to vote at
the General Meeting
|
6.30 p.m. on 31 January
|
Date of
General Meeting
|
11 a.m. on 4
February
|
CQS
Natural Resources Growth and Income PLC
Christopher Casey,
Chairman
|
cnr@tavistock.co.uk
(c/o Tavistock
Communications)
|
Cavendish, Corporate
Broker
Robert Peel, Andrew Worne, Tunga
Chigovanyika
|
+44 20 7908 6000
|
Frostrow Capital LLP, Company
Secretary
Eleanor Cranmer
|
+44 20 3008 4613
cosec@frostrow.com
|
Tavistock, Public
Relations
Jos Simson, Gareth Tredway, Tara
Vivian-Neal
|
+44 20 7920 3150
cnr@tavistock.co.uk
|
Notes to
Editors:
The Company actively invests in global energy
and mining companies, with a focus on total return. It also pays a
regular quarterly dividend. The flexible mandate allows the Company
to shift its portfolio weighting between energy and mining, with
the aim of maximising returns depending on the point in the cycle,
whilst providing relative value opportunities.
The closed end structure is well suited to
allowing the investment management team to focus on the best
returns profile, rather than liquidity as is the case with Exchange
Traded Funds ("ETFs"). The nature of this focus results in the
Company holding a large proportion of its holdings in names that
fall just below major index or ETF inclusion, adding additional
upside potential should they become included. The portfolio is
invested mostly in producers and developers across the natural
resources sector, with strong earnings profiles and market caps
typically in the region of £300m to £2bn, although also below and
above this range.
The majority of holdings are listed in North
America, Australia and/or the UK.
Why should I
vote against all the Saba Capital Management L.P. Requisitioned
Resolutions:
The current
Board:
✔ Has overseen strong
performance, with 167% total return in NAV and 220% total return in
share price since the current joint fund managers were appointed in
October 2015[2].
✔ Believes Manulife |
CQS and the joint fund managers, who are widely recognised as being
leading investors in their field, are the team best placed to
continue this strong performance in the natural resources sector
you have chosen to invest in.
✔ Is fully independent
and has deep experience in investment trusts, natural resources,
the UK investment management sector, finance and accounting, and as
directors of quoted companies.
✔ In line with the
highest standards of corporate governance, maintains an annual
continuation vote which facilitates 100% cash return should that be
the wish of the majority of Shareholders voting.
✔ Is committed to
creating and preserving value for ALL Shareholders.
Saba:
✘ Have failed to state
how much cash they will return to you.
✘ Are expected to
appoint themselves as manager, as set out in their statement to
Shareholders; we believe for their own economic gain.
✘ Are expected to
change your Company's investment policy from the strategy that you
selected, to an approach of investing in other trusts for which no
track record has been provided.
✘ Have failed to narrow
the discounts of the funds that they have taken control of in the
US, compared with their long-term averages, and your investment may
become trapped at a long-term discount.
✘ Have proposed
directors who we do not believe to be independent of Saba, with no
experience in natural resources and who, despite Saba's misleading
claims, appear to have no experience of directing investment
trusts.
Important
information
Capitalised terms used throughout this
announcement shall have the meanings ascribed to them in the
Circular published by the Company on 7 January 2025 (the
"Circular"), unless the context otherwise requires. Permission to
quote from the content of the ISS report was not obtained. Neither
the content of the websites referred to in this announcement, nor
the content of any other website accessible from hyperlinks on such
websites, is incorporated into, or forms part of, this
announcement.