By Val Brickates Kennedy
Pandemic. The word alone evokes images of societal chaos. But is
that what we're really in for this fall, when the world faces its
first official pandemic flu season since 1968?
Not exactly, say public health experts.
"The H1N1 virus could have a profound impact," Jennifer Nuzzo,
an epidemiologist at the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center's
Center for Biosecurity, told MarketWatch recently. "But we're not
talking Hollywood pandemonium here."
That said, healthcare experts are also quick to note that twice
as many people could get sick this flu season, as the recently
identified H1N1 virus and seasonal flu bug work their ways through
the population. The last official flu pandemic was declared in 1968
for the so-called Hong Kong flu, and although it yielded a
relatively low death rate, it still managed to kill about 1 million
worldwide.
Those who dismiss the H1N1 bug, also known as swine flu, as a
hoax like to point out the death rate, so far, has been extremely
low. Seasonal influenza generally kills about 36,000 Americans a
year, while the H1N1 virus has only resulted in 44 confirmed
deaths, as of June 12.
But those numbers are misleading, say health experts. They point
out that the official death count includes only victims whose
diagnoses were confirmed by a special laboratory test. The actual
number of infections is believed to be far higher, and should
continue to climb as the virus gains traction.
Also on the minds of healthcare workers is that flu outbreaks
tend to unfold with a wave of mild infections in the spring,
followed by a more severe wave in the fall.
The fact that the H1N1 bug is a relatively new viral mash-up is
also worrisome, experts say. Because of its novelty, most people
appear to have no immunity to it, as opposed to seasonal flu
viruses, which meander around the globe for years.
"More people could get sick from H1N1 than the seasonal flu
because people have less immunity to it," said Nuzzo. "That's the
conservative fear."
Another major concern is that the public could be bombarded
simultaneously with two highly contagious bugs.
"The biggest worry is if there's an additive effect, it's just a
lot more people in the healthcare system," said Dr. Paul Biddinger,
associate director of the Harvard School of Public Health's Center
for Public Health Preparedness. "Hospitals are already at capacity
and ERs are well above it."
Dodging The Avian Flu Bullet, For Now
One scenario that most experts have ruled out, at least in the
near-term, is that the dreaded H5N1 virus will mutate over the next
few months into an easily-transmitted bug, creating a "perfect
storm" pandemic.
Fortunately, H5N1, or avian flu, is still extremely difficult
for humans to contract. But when they do, the effects are
devastating.
To put the H5N1 virus in perspective, the most deadly pandemic
the world has seen in modern times was the so-called Spanish flu of
1918, which is believed to have killed up to 100 million people
worldwide over the course of two years. The death rate from the
seasonal flu is about 0.1%, while the Spanish flu had an estimated
mortality rate of about 2%.
In comparison, the death rate for H5N1 is between 60% and
70%.
But the Doomsday scenario that H5N1 could rapidly mutate into a
highly contagious plague remains theoretical. While viruses have
been known to turn on a dime, others end up burning out before they
gain major momentum.
Push For H1N1 Vaccine
So what are health officials doing to help us prepare for the
upcoming flu season?
According to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services,
which also oversees the Centers for Disease Control and the Food
and Drug Administration, the government has now shifted its
pandemic planning focus from H5N1 to H1N1 for the upcoming flu
season.
Seasonal flu still remains a priority. The government is still
asking the five U.S.-licensed flu vaccine makers to supply the U.S.
market with about 100 million doses of seasonal flu vaccine, a
request on par with those of recent years. The five licensed makers
include the U.K.'s AstraZeneca PLC (AZN) and GlaxoSmithKline PLC
(GSK); Switzerland's Novartis AG (NVS); France's Sanofi-Aventis
(SNY); and Australia's CSL Ltd., according to the CDC.
For H1N1, however, the goal is to eventually have enough vaccine
for all Americans, or about 300 million people. If the virus turns
out to be more aggressive than originally estimated, recipients may
need two doses of vaccine, which translates into about 600 million
doses, according to HHS.
In late May, HHS directed that $1 billion that had been
previously set aside to purchase pandemic vaccines be used to help
pay for development of an H1N1 vaccine. The funds would also be
used to purchase enough vaccine to inoculate the estimated 20
million members of the nation's so-called critical workforce, which
includes such people as emergency workers, healthcare personnel and
utility plant operators, according to HHS spokeswoman Gretchen
Michael.
One major hurdle is the length of time it takes to manufacture
flu vaccine. Currently, flu vaccine is cultured in fertilized eggs.
The process can take up to six months, a painfully long time to
wait if a pandemic is at hand. It also requires millions of
specialized eggs.
A newer process, which cultures the vaccine in animal cells, is
far speedier, taking around 15 weeks.
Vaccine leader Novartis AG announced earlier this month that it
has produced test batches of H1N1 vaccine using its cell-based
technology. A Novartis spokeswoman said that new process was able
to produce vaccine in just a little over a month.
With HHS' support, Novartis is in the process of building a
cell-based manufacturing plant in North Carolina. The company
already operates a similar facility in Marburg, Germany.
U.S. conglomerate Baxter International (BAX) has also developed
a cell-based process. In a statement to MarketWatch, a Baxter
spokesman said the company was in discussions with the FDA about
securing a license for a cell-based H1N1 vaccine, but did not want
to speculate on the timetable.
Looking To Stretch Vaccine Supply
In another departure from past practice, the U.S. government is
also looking at ordering vaccines that contain immunity boosting
agents called adjuvants, which can help stretch the vaccine
supply.
Adjuvant vaccines are already in use in abroad. But healthcare
experts say U.S. regulators have been wary of them in the past
because of lingering concerns that they can contribute to adverse
reactions.
In its May announcement, HHS said that the $1 billion being put
toward an H1N1 vaccine would also be used for vaccines containing
adjuvants. According to Michael, the agency would go for an
adjuvant vaccine if it needed to procure unusually large amounts in
a relatively short period of time.
And how long will it take before an H1N1 is available?
Health officials have said that they hope by September they will
have done enough human testing with the proposed vaccine to allow
the product to go into mass production.
According to HHS, at current capacity rates, it will take
through February 2010 to produce 600 million doses for the U.S.
market. If an adjuvant is used, production would finish earlier, by
the end of 2009.
In the meantime, HHS is working with health experts to determine
who and how many Americans need to be immunized first.
"It's possible we could be way into the flu season before we
have an adequate quantity of vaccine," said Nuzzo.
-By Val Brickates Kennedy; 415-439-6400;
AskNewswires@dowjones.com