For GE, Dropping KPMG Won't Be Easy
28 March 2019 - 12:25AM
Dow Jones News
By Michael Rapoport
General Electric Co. has signaled it may want to switch to a new
auditor, after more than a century with KPMG LLP. But that might
not be so simple.
One problem: The only other audit firms big enough to take on
GE's massive audit all have potential conflicts of interest that
could block them from doing so.
PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP does GE's tax work, and GE's
600-employee tax-services team is now housed at PwC. Ernst &
Young LLP is one of GE's biggest lobbyists in Washington. Deloitte
& Touche LLP has business ties to GE that a GE unit has said
would pose conflict-of-interest concerns.
GE has had a series of accounting problems in recent years that
KPMG, which has audited GE since 1909, failed to catch. After 35%
of GE shareholders voted last April against KPMG continuing as GE's
auditor, the company said it would explore other options.
GE's audit would be a lucrative prize. The company paid KPMG
$133.3 million in 2018 for its audit and other services, the most
by any U.S.-traded company, according to consulting firm Audit
Analytics. Over the past decade, GE's fees to KPMG have totaled
nearly $1.1 billion.
GE is trying to eliminate at least some of the conflicts to
ensure it can switch auditors, and has implemented new procedures
"to mitigate the cost and complexity" of doing so, the company said
in its proxy statement last week. But it's a complex,
time-consuming process, and GE hasn't specified what changes it
might have to make to its existing arrangements or what they might
cost.
A GE spokeswoman said the company plans to start a formal
auditor-search process after its 2019 audit, which KPMG will
handle. "The ultimate timing of this rotation will depend upon
circumstances at the time," she said.
An EY spokesman said "we fully expect to be able to be
compliant" with conflict-of-interest rules by the time GE makes a
decision. Spokesmen for KPMG, PwC and Deloitte declined to
comment.
Any new auditor would have to follow Securities and Exchange
Commission rules that a company's auditor be "independent" -- free
of any relationships that could compromise its ability to perform a
tough, impartial audit of the company's finances. Auditors aren't
allowed to provide many types of consulting services to their audit
clients, for instance.
That creates a dilemma for big companies like GE: They're often
audited by one of the Big Four while tapping the others for
different services.
"If you want a choice, you need to be careful about the
connections and the relationships you have," said Steve Glover, a
Brigham Young University accounting professor.
PwC took over GE's global tax team in 2017, and it now provides
tax planning, advice and compliance to both GE and other PwC tax
clients. At the time, PwC said the GE tax unit could ultimately
bring in more than $1 billion in yearly revenue.
Auditors can provide certain tax services to their audit
clients, but the breadth of PwC's tax work for GE could create a
conflict, auditor-independence experts say. A lot depends on the
specifics. If PwC advocated for GE on tax issues or did anything
that affected GE's financial statements, it could pose a
problem.
EY has lobbied for GE through its Washington Council Ernst &
Young arm since at least 2005. GE paid the firm $420,000 in 2018,
the most for any lobbyist GE uses, to lobby Congress and the
Treasury Department on tax issues, according to lobbying-disclosure
reports and the Center for Responsive Politics.
Deloitte provides certain nonaudit services for and has business
relationships with GE that would be barred under the SEC's
auditor-independence rules. That disclosure was made by Baker
Hughes in an SEC filing in July 2017, following GE's combination of
its oil and gas business with Baker Hughes. Deloitte had served as
Baker Hughes's auditor.
Write to Michael Rapoport at Michael.Rapoport@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
March 27, 2019 09:10 ET (13:10 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2019 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
GE Aerospace (NYSE:GE)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2024 to May 2024
GE Aerospace (NYSE:GE)
Historical Stock Chart
From May 2023 to May 2024