By Paul Vigna
The total market value of bitcoin crossed $1 trillion on Friday
as the price surged above $55,000.
Passionate backers are fond of saying the digital currency is on
a trajectory "to the moon." For the less faithful, determining
bitcoin's value is much more complicated.
Bitcoin has skyrocketed since the beginning of 2020 when it was
trading around $7,000. A steady stream of institutional demand has
been credited with driving much of that rally. Billionaire
hedge-fund managers disclosed purchases: Paul Tudor Jones called it
a " great speculation." A handful of companies, most notably Tesla
Inc., recently started buying it for their corporate reserves.
Yet determining a fair value for bitcoin is much harder than
valuing stocks, investors say, both because bitcoin isn't a
traditional asset and because much about it is misunderstood.
"It's a difficult asset class to value," said J.P. Morgan
analyst Nikolaos Panigirtzoglou, who estimates the value of one
bitcoin could be as little as $11,000 or as much as $146,000.
The low end of that range is what it currently costs in
computing power to create a bitcoin, he said, while the high end
marks bitcoin's estimated value if its market capitalization were
to match that of gold. Almost any price in between could be
justified because of the intense interest from retail buyers, he
added.
Bitcoin's backers are a passionate bunch, less concerned with
fundamental analysis than a fervent belief that bitcoin is the
future. That ethos is summed up in a single word: hodl, a
misspelling of "hold" from an impassioned 2013 post on a bitcoin
forum by a trader during one of bitcoin's periodic crashes. It
means always keep buying, no matter what, and never sell. To these
people, bitcoin's value is limitless.
To others, determining bitcoin's value is tricky. Bitcoin has
properties that make it appear more like a commodity -- indeed, the
Internal Revenue Service classifies it as such -- and properties
that make it appear more like a currency, as Japan's Financial
Services Agency classifies it.
Yet it really isn't either. Bitcoin is a software program
designed to facilitate online exchange, to mimic physical cash,
without the need for a bank or other middleman to guarantee the
exchange.
One of the most popular arguments for bitcoin? It's a modern
version of gold and a store of value. That belief rests mainly upon
one specific feature of bitcoin's programming, a limit of 21
million placed on the number of bitcoins that could be created.
That, its backers argue, makes bitcoin a scarce commodity and a
deflationary rather than inflationary asset, at least compared with
government-backed currencies.
Bitcoin, however, does have its own rate of inflation, albeit an
entirely predictable one that is designed to decrease in the long
run. Currently, 6.25 bitcoins are created roughly every 10 minutes,
and nearly 19 million of the intended 21 million bitcoins are
already in circulation. That results in a current inflation rate of
roughly 2.2%, according to Bitcoin.com.
For comparison's sake, that is higher than both the Federal
Reserve's stated goal of 2% and the most recent Consumer Price
Index rate of 1.4%.
Bitcoin's inflation rate will drop to zero some time around the
year 2140 when the last of the 21 million bitcoins are minted.
The effective inflation rate is likely higher. Nearly 80% of
bitcoin's supply is illiquid, analytic firm Glassnode estimates,
held by long-term investors who won't sell. Only about 4.2 million
bitcoins are in circulation. That small supply is currently far
outstripped by demand.
Another way of analyzing these dynamics, and one popular among
bitcoiners, is the stock-to-flow model, a framework used to value
commodities like gold and silver, made popular on social media by
an anonymous trader dubbed Plan B.
Stock to flow measures the ratio of existing stockpiles to
production. It is essentially another way of stating bitcoin's
inflation rate. By this model, bitcoin should trade more like gold
and silver, Plan B argued. To the trader's credit, back in 2019
Plan B predicted that the model implied bitcoin should have a $1
trillion market value and trade at $55,000 some time after May
2020. That prediction was fulfilled Friday.
But if bitcoin is supposed to be a gold alternative, its price
is already in line with gold, J.P. Morgan's Mr. Panigirtzoglou
argues. Bitcoin's market value is around $1 trillion, and the
market value of privately held gold is around $2.7 trillion, he
estimates. But in a portfolio that also takes into account
volatility, like one managed by a professional money manager or
corporate treasurer, bitcoin's much higher volatility means that
the two would essentially be evenly weighted, he said.
Because portfolio managers and corporate treasurers need to take
that volatility into account, he said he doesn't expect much more
institutional money to be invested in bitcoin unless its price
tumbles.
"For institutional investors, it is unrealistic here to expect
them to ignore the volatility of bitcoin," he said.
To that point, a Gartner survey last week found only 5% of
finance executives plan to hold bitcoin as a corporate asset in
2021. Moreover, 84% said they never intend to buy bitcoin.
Meanwhile, the highly publicized flurry of institutional
interest in bitcoin may be smaller than it appears. Since
September, only about $11 billion of professional money has entered
the bitcoin market, Mr. Panigirtzoglou estimates. That isn't enough
to drive a $800 billion change in total value and instead suggests
that the attention given to institutional investors has drawn in
more retail interest, he said.
Therefore, what is driving bitcoin's price isn't some
fundamental value proposition, but instead simple retail-driven
momentum trading, Mr. Panigirtzoglou said.
There is a simpler way of defining bitcoin's fundamental value,
according to Steve Hanke, a professor of applied economics at Johns
Hopkins University. Most forms of "money," everything from
commercial bank deposits to Treasury bills, pay some amount of
interest, no matter how small. Bitcoin doesn't. And while
government-issued money doesn't pay interest, it is a universally
recognized means of payment, unlike bitcoin.
"Bitcoin's fundamental value is zero," Mr. Hanke said. "It's
almost all speculative."
Write to Paul Vigna at paul.vigna@wsj.com
(END) Dow Jones Newswires
February 20, 2021 08:14 ET (13:14 GMT)
Copyright (c) 2021 Dow Jones & Company, Inc.
JP Morgan Chase (NYSE:JPM)
Historical Stock Chart
From Apr 2024 to May 2024
JP Morgan Chase (NYSE:JPM)
Historical Stock Chart
From May 2023 to May 2024