The truth about Mongolian government support for foreign investment in Mongolia's mining sector ignored again by Globe and Mail
14 March 2006 - 1:47AM
PR Newswire (US)
Ivanhoe Mines Ltd. issued the following statement today (March 13,
2006) ULAANBAATAR, MONGOLIA, March 13 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- A
story published today in the Toronto Globe and Mail newspaper's
Report on Business section, headlined, "For Ivanhoe, new questions
in Mongolia," follows a disturbing pattern of inaccurate and
misleading accounts by the newspaper and its reporter, Geoffrey
York, during the past 18 months about Ivanhoe Mines' business
interests in Mongolia. The latest story is based almost entirely on
comments made more than three weeks ago by Mongolia's recently
appointed Minister of Industry and Trade, B. Jargalsaikhan,
expressing some personal views about possible state participation
in major mineral deposits in Mongolia. However, the Globe and Mail
and its reporter knew about and ignored an important series of
subsequent statements by senior government representatives
reaffirming the position of the government and outlining the
official, democratic decision-making process now underway. The
reporter knew, and failed to report, that Mongolia's President N.
Enkhbayar, Prime Minister M. Enkhbold and other members of
parliament have made public statements in recent weeks about the
importance of maintaining foreign investment in Mongolia's rapidly
growing mineral sector. The reporter knew, and failed to report,
that Ivanhoe had held cordial and productive meetings with Minister
Jargalsaikhan in recent weeks. The story misleadingly implied that
Minister Jargalsaikhan was member of a government committee
appointed to negotiate a state interest in Ivanhoe's Oyu Tolgoi
project. In fact, the reporter knew and failed to report that the
government committee had been instructed by the Prime Minister to
arrange the completion of a stability agreement covering Ivanhoe's
planned development of the Oyu Tolgoi copper-gold deposits. A story
more complete and diligent in its handling of the facts would have
cast events in Mongolia in a very different light to the narrow,
alarmist tone created by the story published today. Ivanhoe advised
the reporter on Thursday and Friday last week of the importance of
understanding and presenting a fair and balanced report of
developments, and presented him with specific facts and references
in answer to his questions. However, the newspaper instead
proceeded to publish yet another sensation-mongering account
without verifying or presenting important facts that are on the
record and that would have given readers and investors a more
thorough and accurate understanding of current events concerning
Ivanhoe's interests in Mongolia. For example: - The Globe knew and
failed to report that the President of Mongolia, N. Enkhbayar, said
on national television on February 23 that the Mongolian National
Security Council (comprised of the President, the Prime Minister
and Speaker of the Parliament) ultimately will lead the formation
of state policy on future mining industry development. The
President stressed that nothing should be done to jeopardize
foreign investment. - The Globe knew, and failed to report, that
Prime Minister Enkhbold said in a major address January 26 that
protecting and enhancing a favourable environment for foreign
investment was one of the top priorities for the new government.
"We will attach utmost importance to this issue in pursuit of the
country's development goals," he said. - The Globe knew and failed
to report that the Mongolian cabinet met last week and agreed that
it should be a priority to resolve urgent issues concerning the
Mongolian mining sector. - The Globe knew and failed to report that
Prime Minister Enkhbold last week assigned the Deputy Prime
Minister, M. Enkhsaikhan, to take charge of the preparation of a
policy document governing the future development of the mineral
sector. Mr. Enkhsaikhan said that there is a need to finalize the
Oyu Tolgoi stability agreement, and no need to delay it, and that
he plans to have his policy report ready by March 25. - The Globe
knew and failed to report that Finance Minister N. Bayartsaikhan is
a member of the special government committee formed last week to
complete negotiations for a stability agreement with Ivanhoe for
the development of Oyu Tolgoi. Under Mongolian law, it is the
Finance Minister who signs stability agreements on behalf of the
government. - The Globe knew and failed to report that Minister
Jargalsaikhan, in expressing his views about state participation in
mineral projects, has clearly distinguished between major projects
that have been discovered with state funds, and Oyu Tolgoi, which
has been discovered entirely by Ivanhoe with private funds. - The
Globe knew and failed to report that Minister Jargalsaikhan has
directly acknowledged that he cannot forcibly take away any
interest in Oyu Tolgoi from Ivanhoe, which he has said would damage
Mongolia's reputation and stifle foreign investment. The Minister
also has said that he would like the government to buy a
participating interest in Oyu Tolgoi in a business deal with
Ivanhoe Mines. - The Globe knew and failed to report that Ivanhoe
is content at this time with the progress that is being made in its
discussions with representatives of the Mongolian government over
the scheduled development of Oyu Tolgoi. The discussions have led
Ivanhoe to believe that a fair and reasonable agreement will be
achieved. Ivanhoe has stated on several occasions that it intends
to direct the development of Oyu Tolgoi; but since September, 2003,
Ivanhoe has consistently allowed for the possibility of one or more
minority investments in Oyu Tolgoi by state agencies "whose
involvement could be profoundly beneficial for the project's
long-term success." - Finally, Ivanhoe Mines' Chairman Robert
Friedland said today that the company feels obliged to speak out to
protect Mongolia's hard-earned reputation as an excellent recipient
for foreign investment in the country's mining sector and to
protect the interests of the Mongolian people and their government,
as well as all of Ivanhoe's stakeholders. "Ivanhoe has decided to
take the extraordinary step of publishing the reporter's questions
and the detailed responses and references that were provided to him
last week. This will show interested parties throughout the world
the extent of the truth that was known by the reporter and the
newspaper, who instead chose to produce a narrow and alarmist
article and headline that was lacking in journalistic integrity.
Copies of Ivanhoe's detailed correspondence with The Globe reporter
will be posted on the "Truth and Lies" section of the company's
website, http://www.ivanhoemines.com/, as soon as technically
possible later today." Ivanhoe's shares are listed on the New York,
Toronto and Nasdaq stock exchanges under the symbol IVN. Ivanhoe
information contacts in North America Investors: Bill Trenaman
(604) 688-5755 Media: Bob Williamson (604) 688-5755 DATASOURCE:
Ivanhoe Mines Ltd. CONTACT: Ivanhoe information contacts in North
America - Investors: Bill Trenaman (604) 688-5755; Media: Bob
Williamson (604) 688-5755; To request a free copy of this
organization's annual report, please go to http://www.newswire.ca/
and click on Tools for Investors.
Copyright