Lower Investment Returns Drive Revamps Of Insurance Models
06 June 2009 - 4:50AM
Dow Jones News
The good old days of steady investment returns are over, and
insurers may need to adjust.
To Clement B. Booth, Allianz SE's (AZ) management board member
who oversees the company's Anglo insurance markets, lower and
less-predictable investment income is one of the key factors
affecting the industry. Price increases are an inevitable
consequence.
"We are at the end of the soft cycle," Booth said in an
interview this week. After years of steadily falling prices for
commercial insurance, prices are "starting" to harden, and will
continue to do so, he said.
Insurers earn money from premiums they collect and from
investment returns on money set aside for future claims or other
business needs. Lower investment income affects all the business
lines Booth manages - reinsurance, aviation, marine and homeowners
insurance, and the company's variable annuity business.
In a recent speech investment guru Bill Gross, founder of
Allianz-owned bond fund manager Pimco, called it the "new normal,"
a world of "stunted" economic growth that will affect investments
for years to come.
In its commercial insurance lines, Allianz will stick to strict
underwriting, the technical business of determining risk and
setting an appropriate price, even if it costs Allianz some
business. Booth said underpricing insurance risk could lead to
sharp price spikes in future years, which is more disruptive than
the steadier increases he envisions.
In June, Allianz began offering auto insurance in the U.S.,
adding to the high-end homeowners insurance it has offered for
years through its Fireman's Fund subsidiary. Allianz doesn't plan
to follow the current trend toward direct-to-consumer auto
insurance marketing
Booth also sees no point in Allianz combining its various U.S.
life and property insurance businesses, as some insurers have in
order to chase a cross-selling model, adding, "that's not to say we
can't take advantage of synergies."
In its variable annuity business, products will have to be
revamped, but market volatility is making it difficult to develop a
product that offers customers a reasonable return and Allianz a
reasonable profit, Booth said. The company stopped selling its
previous "unsustainable" variable annuity product in March.
Other variable annuity sellers have found themselves in the same
position, and many have raised prices and cut back on features that
offer guaranteed minimum rates of return.
Allianz plans to relaunch a new, pared down annuity product in
the third quarter, but the continued market volatility is making it
difficult to settle on pricing and features.
If the company can hit on the right balance, Booth sees a
"changed attitude" among American consumers, many of whom are
setting aside money rather than spending it on discretionary
purchases such as new cars.
He sees "demand-driven potential" for investment products like
annuities if insurers can build them with the right features and a
decent return. "We will do everything we can to stay in the
game."
Shares of Allianz are down 47.2% in the last 12 months, slightly
outperforming the Dow Jones US Life Insurance Index (DJUSIL-DJX),
which is down 50.9% over the same period.
-By Lavonne Kuykendall, Dow Jones Newswires; 312-750 4141;
lavonne.kuykendall@dowjones.com
-0-